Category Archives: Music & Emotion

Music & Neurosciences V – Blog 7 (Musical Emotions)

Hello Dear Reader

I hope you will forgive my lapse on the afternoon of Day 3. I was late staying at the poster session so I missed the start of symposium 7 on “The Beat” as a structured environment for movement, communication and socialization. This was a shame but having missed the start I decided  to have a rest so that I was refreshed for the final session of the day.

If you are interested in this Beat symposium, organised by Katie Overy, then you can find all the abstracts online.

music_emotion_by_zer0byt3-d31moacA little frayed but rested, I headed back for the final symposium of the day organised by Stefan Koelsch and Robert Zatorre on Music and Emotion. The symposium aimed to provide links between scientific research on the neural correlates of musically evoked emotions on the one hand, and therapy and rehabilitation on the other.

First, we heard from Stefan himself. I wrote a recent blog on his excellent review article on music and emotion  so I won’t go too much into the detail. Suffice to say, emotion in music modulates a complex network or areas in the brain that are linked to the reward system.

However, there is one brain area of interest in particular to this talk as it is consistently activated by musical emotion but not by other primary rewards (food, sex) or secondary rewards (money, power) – the hippocampus

hippocampusStefan links the hippocampal activation to the social rewards and functions of music, seven of which he identified in a recent paper.

The big 7 are 1) social contact, 2) social cognition, 3) co-pathy (empathy), 4) communication 5) co-ordination, 6) cooperation and 7) social cohesion.

Stefan’s conclusion was that the power of music to alter neuronal structures with such important links to social function means that it has potential as a treatment for disorders that are marked by dysfunctions of these same skills.

If you want a quick giggle then view this video of Stefan, which he used to start his talk. I can think of other ways to introduce the idea of the brain reward system but in none of these will see Stefan in a white coat pronouncing on the symptoms of One Direction fans… (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2SCyHaqKi50)

brainsThe second talk of the symposium was provided by Robert Zatorre who went into further detail about his work on the activity of dopamine within the brain reward system.

He showed classic data that dopamine uptake in one brain area, the striatum, looks very similar when a person is listening to music or under the influence of narcotics.

As you might imagine, the science media just love this… http://cosmosmagazine.com/news/like-a-drug-music-induces-same-chemicals/

This work was followed up by more studies showing how the time course of our reward response (expectation and consumption of reward) is marked by different stages of dopamine release in the brain. I wrote about this finding for a previous blog: http://musicpsychology.co.uk/music-and-chills-the-brains-reward-system-in-action/

In the present talk Robert went on to discuss investigations of almost the opposite phenomenon – musical anhedonia – reduced pleasure in response to music.

Music_by_BalakovThere are people who derive little pleasure from listening to music. They are not amusic (tone-deaf) but report that music does not please them. They are less likely to seek out music or be interested in its production. Interest in this phenomenon has lead to the development of the Barcelona Music Reward Questionnaire (BMRQ: 2013) – you can take the scale here – http://www.brainvitge.org/bmrq.php

To date, the BMRQ has been taken by just over 850 people and Robert reported that about 5% of them meet a level of musical anhedonia.

medical-158177_640In tests these people show lower skin conductance to pleasurable music (less physiological arousal) and fewer changes to heart rate – yet they are not generally anhedonic as they show normal responses to an unexpected reward in a gambling task.

Musical anhedonia may represent a disconnection between a normal music processing system and the reward network.

Finally, we heard from Patrik Vuilleumier who talked about his work on the neural network underlying musical emotions. He studies the neural correlates of different musical emotions as measured using the Geneva Emotional Music Scale, the 9 factor version http://www.zentnerlab.com/psychological-tests/geneva-emotional-music-scales

Patrik has analysed the components of this scale and mapped the 9 elements of musical emotions into 4 simple quadrants. His research has uncovered distinct patterns of activation associated with these quadrants. I was not able to write them all down (there were a lot of brain images!) but they differentiate, for example, activity in motor and more sensory areas.

cropped-JPSWomanPlayingPiano2.jpgIt is nice to see the study of music and emotion moving into new areas and challenging assumptions, such as 1) music emotion response is mostly visceral, 2) everyone loves music and 3) musical emotions can be summarised on a few dimensions such as happy or sad.

In testing and pushing back these boundaries we move closer to an understanding of how musical interventions may one day be useful as ancillary treatments for emotion disorders.

 

Music, emotion and the brain

Hello Dear Reader

York!
Beautiful York – I missed you!

This week has been one of the busiest of my life. I sold my London flat, bought a house back in my wonderful home town of York, and of course published my baby.

You Are The Music was very briefly the number one selling music book on Amazon last week, a fact that still astonishes and humbles me. I really enjoy the idea that I am making a contribution to music, however small.

I have rarely been so proud and grateful in my life: thank you, Dear Reader.

Now that the book is out there in the big wide world I am starting to hear what people think of it. That is, people other than my family and publisher, two rather biased sources of feedback. So far the word is good, there have been some kind and thoughtful reviews for which I am eternally grateful.

To be honest, I am more sensitive than I had assumed to these reviews: it’s funny how deeply you can feel towards what amounts to a pile of paper and words about music.

Speaking of deep emotion connections to music, I have just finished a cracking review on research into the brain correlates of music-evoked emotions by Stefan Koelsch and published in Nature Reviews Neuroscience.

The subject of music and emotions is one of the most heavily researched in the field of music psychology. This is not too surprising as it plays to a core question for our discipline – why does music change the way that we feel? Koelsch’s new article filters and frames decades of brain research in this area in an easily digestible and, in many places, surprising summary.

Trinity_Academy_of_Irish_DanceKoelsch first talks about the earliest (i.e. most primitive) brain origins of music evoked emotions.  As soon as music hits the ear it stimulates spinal motor neurons and vestibular, visceral systems.

These activations are responsible for some of the arousing effects of music and may also contribute to the feeling we get that when music makes us want to ‘move to the beat’.

Next, Koelsch talks about the core emotion brain network and focuses down on three main candidates: the amygdala, the nucleus accumbens and the hippocampus.

AmygdalaThe amydala (from the Greek amygdale, ‘almond’) is a deep, central brain structure that receives some of the first projections from the lower brain centres. Music stimulates the amydala in a similar way to faces, smells and other sounds, most likely because all these stimuli are perceived as having social significance due to their communicative properties.

According to Koelsch the amygdala is part of a larger network that regulates approach-withdrawal behaviour in response to socio-affective cues, including those given by music.

Finally, the amygdala likely has a role in how we evaluate and learn about positive as well as negative stimuli and therefore is involved in how our behaviour eventually becomes reinforced towards or away from certain musical sounds.

Wall_Street_Sign_NYCNext, the nucleus accumbens (NA). The NA is well known to be activated by peak emotional experiences, known as chills or frisson  but it is also activated as soon as music is experienced as pleasurable. In general the NA is sensitive to primary rewards (food, sex) and secondary rewards (money, power), so it represents hedonic value for us and helps to initiate behaviors that aim to obtain more of these rewards for consumption.

This finding suggests that music can be a very rewarding emotional stimulus: a fact that few music lovers would doubt. The NA activation signals the anticipation of the rewarding experience of hearing pleasurable music, as well as the actual experience of enjoying the music. It also has a role in predicting whether we go on to acquire the track for ourselves.

Hippocampus_and_seahorse_croppedFinally, Koelsch moves on to the hippocampus (from the Greek hippos meaning “horse” and kampos meaning “sea monster” – it looks like a little seahorse!) Now, here is a brain structure that I thought I knew quite well because it is so involved in memory (my main research interest).

But I learned new things about the hippocampus from this article.

Firstly, I learned that the hippocampus is connected to our emotional reactions via its involvement in the regulation of our brain’s chemical stress response, which comprises the hypothalamus, pituitary and adrenal glands all acting in synchrony. The hippocampus is implicated in music-evoked positive emotions that can, in effect, pacify this system, reducing the release of stress hormones like cortisol.

Apparently the hippocampus is quite sensitive to chronic levels of these kinds of stress hormones in general and long term exposure, for example in some cases of PTSD and depression, can damage the neurons in this brain structure. This damage may have consequences for the way that someone reacts to positive stimuli as well as their sensitivity to levels of oxytocin, a neurochemical that promotes social bonding.

The fact that the hippocampus reacts to emotional music (including fear and joy) suggests that it is responsive to the potential of music to stimulate the release of brain chemicals that affect its function, by virtue of that music’s emotional associations and core meaning.

The article then goes on to support the role of these three structures (the amygdala, the nucleus accumbens and the hippocampus) in emotional regulation by citing studies of patients with brain lesions in those areas. Lesions or degenerative damage in these areas can impair the ability to perceive or react to emotion in music.

happyHow does music actually evoke emotion? 

Of course there is the debate surrounding whether music really stimulates actual emotions, but Koelsch argues that it does (at least in part) because musical emotions have all the signs of ‘real’ emotions including bodily reactions, facial expressions, and action responses (such as dancing, singing, and crying).

So if we assume that at least some musical emotions are the genuine article, how does music make us feel this way? 

Koelsch identifies four sources within music itself (i.e. not its memory associations) that can trigger emotional reactions : 1) acoustic factors (e.g. consonance/dissonance, loudness); 2) structural stability (e.g. moving to and from the tonal centre); 3) the extent of structural content in the music; and 4) structural breaches.

Lövheim_cube_of_emotionTherefore, one of the sources of emotion in music relates strongly to our responses to any sound (number 1) while the other three are down to the way that composers play with the structure within music as it progresses, creating an ebb and flow of tension and relaxation, that in the right quantities provide the recipes for different emotional reactions.

 

Another interesting source of emotion is referred to as ‘contagion’: The idea that once an emotion is triggered, we experience the physiological manifestations of that state – so, for example, we might smile. That smile then feeds back into the system and reinforces the happy emotion that we feel.

0Koelsch finishes the article with a few words about the potential of the emotional power of music to have measurable effects when applied in therapeutic/ medicinal settings. The key is evidence that music can change activity in brain structures that might otherwise be damaged in conditions such as PTSD, depression, and dementia. We have yet to know whether music has a strong enough effect to ameliorate the brain basis of some of these conditions and therefore reduce the symptoms, but the theoretical potential is there.

Click here for a previous blog about the power of music and memory that features Henry, the man in the image above.

In sum, this detailed and well researched article provides an excellent overview of the ways in which music can evoke activity in core areas of the brain that underlie our experience of emotion, and outlines some of the ways in which the music itself can trigger these changes.

With this wealth of evidence in the bag it is now time to broaden the horizons in this field and move into lesser explored territories such as music and emotion in children and ageing populations, as well as the above mentioned exciting possibilities for therapy/medicine.

Article: Koelsch, S (2014) Brain correlates of music-evoked emotions. Nature Reviews Neuroscience, 15, 170-180